Cashbox vs spreadsheets

4 min read

Your spreadsheet isn't the problem. The handoffs are.

Where spreadsheets still work for event budgets, where they break (approvals, FX, audit trail, per-event P&L), and what Cashbox does instead.

Spreadsheet

The right place to start

A spreadsheet is the right place to start an event budget. Everyone on the team can open one, nobody needs training, and a single show with one person holding the numbers rarely needs anything else.

Fine while one person holds the numbers

Cashbox

Budget, spend and approvals in one place

Cashbox becomes useful when the budget, the spend, the approvals and the receipts belong to several people. This page is an honest look at where that line falls, and at what changes when they all live in one place.

For when the budget is shared

Side by side

Feature by feature

What each one does for an event budget, from the first line to the hand-off.

15 capabilities compared

CapabilitySpreadsheet Cashbox
Budget and actuals
Budget per event, by categorySpreadsheet YesCashboxYes
Actuals roll up as expenses landSpreadsheetManual formulasCashboxYes
Same structure on every eventSpreadsheetCopy of the last fileCashboxYes
Portfolio view across open eventsSpreadsheetLinked sheetsCashboxYes
Spend and approvals
Receipt attached to the lineSpreadsheetLink to a driveCashboxYes
Capture from a phone at the venueSpreadsheet NoCashboxYes
Approval over a spend thresholdSpreadsheetEmail threadCashboxYes
Record of who approved what, and whenSpreadsheet NoCashboxYes
Money
Original currency kept on every lineSpreadsheetIf someone remembersCashboxYes
Exchange rate stored at entrySpreadsheet NoCashboxYes
History unchanged when rates moveSpreadsheet NoCashboxYes
Access and hand-off
Roles with different permissionsSpreadsheetShare settingsCashboxFour roles
CSV export for your accountantSpreadsheet YesCashboxYes
Works offlineSpreadsheet YesCashboxNo
CostSpreadsheetFreeCashboxFrom €39/month
Production manager backstage at a festival, photographing a receipt with a phone next to the road cases
Filed at the venue

The receipt goes onto the expense from the side of the stage, not into a pocket to be typed up next week.

Kept on every expense

  • The receipt, attached to the line
  • The original currency and amount
  • The exchange rate on the day it was entered
  • Who approved it and when, above your threshold
What goes wrong

Where it breaks

  1. Every event starts as a copy of the last one

    The master template gets duplicated, a formula gets fixed in one copy and not the others, and by the third show of the season the files no longer agree on what a category means. Comparing two events turns into reconciling two spreadsheets first.

    In Cashbox every event uses the same structure, so actuals roll up the same way on every show, and the portfolio view reads across all of them without anyone linking sheets together.

  2. Approvals live in email

    Who said yes to the staging upgrade? The answer is in a thread called "Re: re: invoice", if it is anywhere. A spreadsheet can hold the number but not the decision behind it.

    In Cashbox a spend over your threshold goes to management for approval, and the approval is recorded on the expense: who approved it, when, and with the receipt attached. Anything under the threshold posts straight to the ledger.

  3. Currencies drift

    A festival with an international line-up pays fees in one currency, sells tickets in another, and books suppliers in a third. In a spreadsheet the exchange rate is whatever someone typed on the day, and when a rate cell gets updated, every historical total that referenced it quietly changes too.

    Cashbox keeps the original currency on every line and stores the rate at the moment the line is entered. Last season's numbers stay last season's numbers when rates move.

  4. Receipts are somewhere else

    Receipts arrive as photos in chat threads and scans in someone's downloads folder. The sheet has a row for the expense; the evidence lives elsewhere, if it survives at all.

    In Cashbox the receipt is attached to the expense it belongs to. On a phone the capture button opens the camera, so a stage manager can file a fuel receipt at the venue instead of carrying it home.

  5. You find out the margin weeks later

    When actuals are typed in after the fact, the P&L only exists once the bookkeeping catches up, often after the next show is already in build. Whatever the numbers say by then is too late to act on.

    In Cashbox revenue and expenses land on the same event as they happen, so the P&L is current during the show, not reconstructed after it.

Switching over

Moving from a spreadsheet

You don't have to start from nothing.

CSV

Import the sheet you have

Cashbox imports expenses and revenue from Excel or CSV, and the importer maps your existing column names and categories instead of making you reshape the file first. You can bring over the current season and leave older files where they are.

Free

A template shaped for the import

If you're starting a budget from scratch, our free festival budget template comes in a version shaped for that import.

Get the template

15 days

Try it on a real event

There is a 15-day free trial with no card, so you can import a real event and compare it against your sheet before deciding.

Honest assessment

Where a spreadsheet still wins

  • It costs nothing

    If you run one show a year with a small crew, a well-kept sheet is hard to beat on price.

  • It bends to anything

    A new column, a one-off calculation, a scenario tab: a spreadsheet never tells you no.

  • It works without a connection

    Cashbox is a web app and needs signal to save. A spreadsheet on a laptop does not.

  • Your accountant already reads it

    Cashbox is not accounting software either. It exports to CSV for whoever files the books.

If that describes your year, keep the spreadsheet.

Try it on a real event

Import one event and compare it with your sheet.

Bring the spreadsheet you already have, as Excel or CSV. The importer maps your columns and categories, so you see your own numbers in Cashbox on day one.

  • 15-day free trial
  • No card required
  • Excel and CSV import included